Management as a Liberal Art Research Institute

Management and Leadership in Peter Drucker’s Writings

Pooya Tabesh, Ph.D.

PUBLISHED:

May 16, 2022

Peter Drucker has written a lot on management and leadership, but where did he stand in terms of his focus on the constructs of management and leadership? Was he more concerned with “managing” or “leading” in his writings? To take Drucker by his words, I conducted a computer-aided text analysis on all Drucker’s published books to objectively compare the number of times “manage” and “lead” have appeared in his writings. This way, I compared the relative frequency of words starting with “manage” (including manger, management, etc.) with “lead” (e.g., lead, leadership, leader etc.) in all Drucker books excluding novels.


Word Frequency Results

Using the machine-readable text versions of all Drucker’s books, I analyzed the relative word frequencies on Voyant Tools which is a powerful publicly available tool for computational linguistic (Sinclair & Rockwell, 2016). The figure below shows the frequency with which terms “manage” and “lead” have appeared in each of Peter Drucker's written contributions. As evident in this figure, in 29 out of 32 of Drucker’s books, the relative frequency of “manage” is significantly higher than “lead”.

Graph displaying frequency of “manage” and “lead” in each of Peter Drucker's writings.

Similarly, I ran the same analysis at the aggregate level to compare the total number of times Drucker has used these words in his books. Looking at the aggregate frequencies (The total number of appearances in all 32 books), words including “lead” have appeared around 3010 times while words including “manage” appeared 13532 times. Thus, Drucker has used “manage” more than four times more frequently than “lead”.


Conclusion

This analysis shows that based on the frequency of words written by the author, Peter Drucker has put a far greater emphasis on the construct of management than the construct of leadership, throughout his writing career. This finding is not surprising considering Drucker’s dedication to general management topics. Nevertheless, this finding does not mean that Drucker has ignored leadership as an important organizational phenomenon. Drucker has written a lot about leadership and believed that effective leadership is less dependent on leader’s charisma and personality and more dependent on a leader’s ability for thinking through organizational mission. In this regard, Drucker had a very critical view of certain over-glorified views of leadership. Particularly, his negative views of charismatic leadership are evident in many of his writings. For instance, he believes that “The three most charismatic leaders in this century inflicted more suffering on human earth than almost any trio in history: Hitler, Stalin, and Mao (Drucker, 1990)”. Drucker considered leadership as “the essential” management skill.


For a deep understanding of Peter Drucker’s thoughts on leadership, I invite you to read “Drucker on leadership: New lessons from the father of modern management” by William A. Cohen (Cohen, 2009). In addition, Teo-Dixon and Monin (2007), have conducted an interesting study to track the evolution of the meaning of “leadership” through time in various Peter Drucker books and articles. 



References

Cohen, W. A. (2009). Drucker on leadership: New lessons from the father of modern management. John Wiley & Sons.

Drucker, P. (1990). Managing the non-profit organization: Practices and principles. Harper Collins Publishers 

Teo-Dixon, G., & Monin, N. (2007). Guru of gurus: Peter Drucker, logology, and the ultimate leader. Journal of Management Inquiry, 16(1), 6-17.

Number Title
1 The End of Economic Man (1939)
2 The Future of Industrial Man (1942)
3 Concept of the Corporation (1946)
4 The New Society (1950)
5 The Practice of Management (1954)
6 America's Next Twenty Years by Peter F. Drucker (1957)
7 Managing for Results (1964)
8 The Effective Executive (1967)
9 The Age of Discontinuity. Guidelines to Our Changing Society (1969)
10 Technology, Management and Society (1970)
11 Men, Ideas and Politics (1971)
12 The New Markets and other Essays (1971)
13 The Unseen Revolution (1976)
14 People and Performance (1977)
15 Managing in Turbulent Times (1980)
16 Toward the next economics, and other essays (1981)
17 The Changing World of the Executive (1982)
18 Innovation and Entrepreneurship Clean (1985)
19 The Frontiers of Management: Where Tomorrow's Decisions Are Being Shaped Today (1986)
20 Management - Tasks, Responsibilities, Practices (1986)
21 The New Realities (1989)
22 Managing the Non-Profit Organization (1990)
23 Managing for the Future by Peter Drucker (1992)
24 Post-capitalist Society (1993)
25 The Ecological Vision (1993)
26 Managing in a Time of Great Change by Drucker (1995)
27 Peter Drucker on the Profession of Management (1998)
28 Managing Oneself (1999)
29 Management Challenges for the 21st Century (1999)
30 The Essential Drucker- basically only kept afterword (2001)
31 Managing in the Next Society (2002)
32 A Functioning Society (2003)
By Karen Linkletter Ph.D. January 6, 2025
On December 13, 2024, we lost a seminal management philosopher and theorist: Charles Handy. Like Peter Drucker, Handy was a social thinker and management theorist who emphasized the human side of work as more important than profits and valued individual growth and development in organizations. Handy was born in Ireland and studied at Oxford. In 1956, he went to work for Shell, working in Borneo, where he met his future wife, Elizabeth Hill. Disillusioned by corporate life, Handy left Shell in 1962 to study management at MIT in their executive program. Inspired by their humanistic approach, he returned to London in 1967 to start the London Business School. Handy knew Drucker and was a regular keynote speaker at the Global Drucker Forum in Vienna. The two men had much in common in terms of their approaches to management and social theory. Like Drucker, Handy became an author (although, unlike Drucker, Handy was a corporate executive before he turned to writing). Handy wrote not just on business but also society, serving as much as a social ecologist as Drucker was. In his pivotal book, The Age of Unreason (1989), Handy argued for the disruption of discontinuity – resulting in a new world of business, education, and work that was highly unpredictable. He rejected shareholder capitalism and saw the organization as a place for human purpose and fulfillment, based on trust. Like Drucker, Handy advocated federalism in organizations, disseminating authority and responsibility to the lowest possible levels. He also saw “the future that had already happened.” Handy coined the term “portfolio life,” where knowledge workers would increasingly work remotely and for multiple organizations. In the 1980s, he posited that society consisted of “shamrock organizations”: those that had three integrated leaves: full-time employees, outside contractors, and temporary workers. Handy thus foresaw the new “gig economy” and increasingly autonomy of knowledge work. Finally, like Drucker, Handy had a life partner who not only supported his career but was an independent woman with her own interests. Liz Handy, like Doris Drucker, was an entrepreneur who ran an interior design business, and later was a professional photographer and Charles’s business agent.  Minglo Shao, founder of CIAM, remembers Handy as a warm man who made several important contributions to what we see as the fundamentals of Management as a Liberal Art. We are thankful for Handy’s contributions to management theory and social thought, and for his legacy at the Global Drucker Forum in the form of the Charles and Elizabeth Handy Lecture Series.
By Richard and Ilse Straub with the Drucker Forum Team December 29, 2024
For 15 years, Charles Handy did us the enormous honor of choosing the Drucker Forum as a privileged platform for delivering his message to the world, and particularly to the younger generation in which he had such faith. Following up on our initial announcement of Charles’ passing Charles Handy (1932–2024) , we are honored to share a selection of his key contributions to the Forum with our wider community. Charles’ brilliant keynotes at the Drucker Forum have become legendary. Normally accessible only to members of the Drucker Society, from today they are available as recordings to the wider public for a period of 30 days. At the first centennial Forum in 2009, Charles talked about his debt to Peter Drucker while outlining his own fundamental management concepts that he had developed over the years. Two years later, he touched on the ideas of Adam Smith and demonstrated how much more to them there was than the celebrated “invisible hand” of self-interest. In his landmark closing address in 2017, pursuing a thread developed in his 2015 book The Second Curve, he called for a management reformation that would turn it into a tool for the common good – thus drawing the first contours of what we would announce six years later as the Next Management . We took to heart his exhortation not to wait for great leaders but “to start small fires in the darkness, until they spread and the whole world is alight with a better vision of what we could do with our businesses”. Management’s "second curve" will be the focus of the “Charles and Elizabeth Handy Lecture Series” in 2025. Following the loss of his beloved wife Elizabeth in 2018 and a severe stroke, Charles was much reduced in mobility in his last years – but not in his determination to continue spreading his message of hope to the world. He couldn’t participate in person in the Drucker Forum 2022, but he participated in a moving online interview with his son Scott, who directed young actors in a short performance of Beckett’s Waiting for Godot by Beckett to illustrate some points.  Charles also contributed valued digital articles for our blog and for Drucker Forum partners. Even during the most difficult period of his life he continued to write and develop his ideas in weekly columns for the Idler magazine. This entailed first memorizing the article, then dictating it and finally reviewing it by having someone it re-read to him – a remarkable feat of memory and determination. The article is a jewel and most appropriate for Christmas and the season of self-reflection. Have a wonderful Christmas, happy holidays and a healthy and prosperous New Year.
By Karen Linkletter Ph.D. November 19, 2024
Interview with Karen Linkletter at the 16th Global Peter Drucker Forum 2024  Video Interview
Show More
Share by: